Monday, August 30, 2010

DECEPTION: The Constant Flood of Domestic Violence Commercials and Public Service Announcements that Portray Demonizing Stereotypes of Men and Wrong-H

If you watch any domestic violence video, in commercial form, or even a police training video, you'll notice that the information presented is incorrect, and the man is ALWAYS marked as the villain.

TRUTH:

Women commit domestic violence for the same reasons that men do.
In a study, men and women both gave the same reasons for assaulting their partners. The most common reason was, "to get through to them".
(Carrado, "Aggression in British Heterosexual Relationships; A Descriptive Analysis," Aggressive Behavior, (1996) 22: 401-415.)

BRAINWASHING:
By showing only violent men, and no violent or hysterical women on such ads, they are painting a warped picture of men being monsters and women being saints.

This instills fear and mistrust of men in women.

Since no abusive women are shown in such videos, it re-inforces the "I am woman, I can do no wrong" attitude.

MY SEARCH ON YOUTUBE
Well, I did a search on YOUTUBE for "Domestic Violence". Below are the search results. Each one show:

Whether or not an angry or violent man was shown or implied.
Whether or not an angry or violent woman was shown or implied.
Whether or not a beaten man was shown or implied.
Whether or not a beaten woman was shown or implied.
I also tried to identify which ones had FALSE or MISLEADING statistics in them.


VIEWSYouTubeDescriptionAngry ManAngry WomanBeaten ManBeaten WomanFalse Stats
285,977LINKAustralian man hands another man a bat!YesNoNoNoNo
58,993LINKMovie clip with Farrah FaucetYesNoNoYesNo
13,432LINKMusic with pictures of beaten womenNoNoNoYesNo
70,279LINKRapper on Domestic ViolenceYesNoNoYesNo
258,322LINKWaitress spills coffee on a man.YesNoNoYesNo
28,755LINKA Woman leaves an abusive relationship.YesNoNoYesNo
513,969LINKClip from a movie.YesNoNoYesNo
10,464LINKA Woman crying...YesNoNoYesYes
7,722LINKMusic Video?????
33,675LINKMovie Clip - a man abusing a womanYesNoNoYesNo
???LINKSet of Videos about Female ViolenceNoNoNoNoNo
2,848LINKPanel Discussion about Domestic Violence on Children?????
1,573LINKTwo Women talk about Getting Beat UpYesNoNoYesNo
3,917LINKVarious ImagesYesNoNoYesNo
23,809LINKIslamic Sermon about Domestic ViolenceNoNoNoNoNo
58,533LINKPatrick Stewart Domestic ViolenceYesNoNoYesYes
???LINKLink to Series of Public Service Announcements?????
46,325LINKMedia Hype about Rhianna/Chris BrownYesNoNoYesNo
4,694LINKText PresentationNoNoNoNoYes
110,929LINKA Child's Tea PartyYesNoNoYesNo
31,387LINKShows a beaten womanNoNoNoYesNo
1,712LINKOne Woman's StoryYesNoNoYesNo
6,242LINKWOW! A Men's Rights Group Sues!NoNoYesNoNo
16,087LINKNear the end - Its talks about Domestic ViolenceYesNoNoYesNo
76,118LINKInterview with a WomanYesNoNoYesYes
9,835LINKA Man Getting HitNoYesYesNoNo
4,694LINKIdentical to the one above with 4,694 views.NoNoNoNoYes
217LINKA Seminar - all female speakers.?????
4,596LINKSea-Lion Domestic Violence.NoNoNoNoNo
19,280LINKA Fair Approach.YesYesYesYesYes
19,047LINKShows Violent Men.YesNoNoYesNo
11,906LINKOnly shows Violence against women.YesNoNoYesNo
5,607LINKImages of Beaten Women.NoNoNoYesNo
6,071LINKSome more False statistics...NoNoNoNoYes
2,110LINKMore images of Beaten Women...NoNoNoYesNo
8,134LINKGay Men Domestic Violence Polar Plunge???????
5,883LINKStory of a woman in India.YesNoNoYesNo
6,511LINKMemorial for a Woman.YesNoNoYesNo
TOTAL2123246

Here are the stats:

55%Show or imply an angry or violent man.
5%Show or imply an angry or violent woman.
8%Show or imply a man getting hit.
63%Show or imply a woman getting hit.


And - 18% Have FALSE or MISLEADING statistics!
The problem is, just over 50% of all Domestic Violence is perpetrated by WOMEN!
One thing in particular I noticed: Most videos almost literally show a woman with a halo above her head, and a man wearing demon horns. That is, mis-leading stereotypes of both men and women were being shown in the videos - deragotory ones for men, excessively positive ones for women. Also, the videos rarely showed an argument leading up to violence. Most simply implied that men just hit women for no reason whatsoever. And of course, women never hit men.

Talk about mis-representation!

No comments:

Post a Comment